The GCR Network

Grayscale GBTC and ETHE Arbitrage Risks

This is a contributing article from Amber Group.

Join the Global Coin Research Network now and contribute your thoughts on Asia!


The GBTC and ETHE premium arbitrage trade has recently become very topical. Both products, issued by Grayscale, have traded at a consistent premium over NAV (TradeBlock XBX and ETX Index) since inception. Currently, GBTC trades at a 30% premium to NAV, and ETHE trades at a 850% premium to NAV.

Whilst the secondary market trades at a premium to NAV, there are ways to subscribe to shares struck at NAV:

  1. In cash, using USD to buy shares struck at NAV
  2. In-kind, by sending BTC or ETHE to the trust and receiving shares struck at NAV

After a lockup period, investors may pull their shares into a brokerage account as an equal number of ETHE or GBTC shares, which they can then sell at market prices. Grayscale charges a 2% annual management fee on GBTC and a 2.5% annual fee on ETHE which the investor pays during the holding period. The lockup period for GBTC is 6 months, and 12 months for ETHE. If the premium is still positive after shares unlock, investors can pocket the difference in the spread. Below we outline the trade setup for 3 broad types of market participants.

For USD-denominated investors:

  1. Investor sends USD to the trust and subscribes to shares struck at NAV
  2. Shares are locked for 6m in GBTC / 12m in ETHE, and upon unlock, investor sell the shares at the prevailing market price
  3. If the premium persists upon unlock, he/she is able to realize the spread
  4. This is ideal for investors who wish to gain BTC or ETH exposure and monetize their view on a sustained premium (as a way to enhance yield)

For BTC and ETH-denominated investors:

  1. Investor sends coins to the trust and subscribes to shares struck at NAV
  2. Shares are locked for 6m in GBTC / 12m in ETHE, and upon unlock, investor sell the shares at the prevailing market price
  3. As there exists no in-kind redemption, the investor needs to use proceeds from the share sales to buy back physical coins in order to return to his/her base portfolio
  4. This is ideal for investors who wish to earn more coins and monetize their view on a sustained premium

For market neutral investors

  1. Investor borrows coins from a lender, and subscribes to shares struck at NAV
  2. Shares are locked for 6m in GBTC / 12m in ETHE, and upon unlock, investor sell the shares at the prevailing market price
  3. Investor needs to then use the USD proceeds to buy back the physical coins (BTC or ETH)
  4. Investor pays back the coin principal to the lender, and the interest
  5. This is ideal for market neutral investors who wish to express a view on a sustained premium, and are able to borrow coins at a funding cost within their expected premium (less accrued management fees)

None of these trades would constitute an arbitrage per se. In each of the above cases, investors need to sell the shares in the secondary market, and are subject to market fluctuations in the spread/premium, with no direct way to hedge. Whilst historically the shares have traded at steep premiums to NAV, premiums could compress, or trade at discounts in the future. Below are a few examples of potential headwinds against a sustained premium.

First to the finish

Firstly, as subscriptions (70% of which are in-kind) have grown tremendously over the past few quarters, this is likely indicative of “arbitrage” traders looking to monetize the premium. Given the growth in popularity of this trade, there will be increasingly more sell pressure on GBTC and ETHE as shares from earlier subscriptions begin to unlock. This makes the market more conducive to spread compression.

No redemption program

Currently, BTC and ETH that are sent to the trust never leave the trust. So whilst investors can subscribe in-kind, they can not redeem in-kind (exchange shares for underlying coins). Hence, there is nothing stopping the shares from potentially trading at a discount to NAV should spot significantly outperform / shares underperform on a swift market move.

In-kind redemptions

Currently, BTC that are sent to the trust never leave the trust. Whilst it may not be in their best interest — introducing redemptions where investors could redeem GBTC and ETHE shares for underlying BTC and ETHE would make the products immediately arbitragable, closing the spread.

Reduced lockup periods

Secondly, the lockup period could continue to reduce for private placement investors. Earlier this year, following approval from the SEC, the previous 12 month holding period was reduced to the current 6 month period in GBTC. Should the lockup period reduce again in the future, this could translate into further sell pressure on the shares from existing subscriptions.

More stock borrow availability

Historically, trust shares have been scarce in supply, making securities borrow difficult and expensive. Investors have therefore been unable to short GBTC against the underlying. With the GBTC trust AUM now at $3.7bn and growing (ETHE @ $360mio and growing), shares are likely to become easier to borrow with higher availability as the public float grows.

Competing products

As high entry-barriers and difficulty of crypto-access continue to subside (Robinhood, Coinbase), premiums should naturally compress over time as investors find alternative ways to buy underlying assets directly. An ETF approval (albeit chances may be slim currently) would serve as a key catalyst for institutional buyers to switch over from GBTC as the preferred instrument to hold.

Against the above headwinds, the main tailwind to a sustained premium would be continued and sustained investor demand.

DISCLAIMER

The information contained in this post (the “Information”) has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is in summary form, and does not purport to be complete. The Information is not, and is not intended to be, an offer to sell, or a solicitation of an offer to purchase, any securities.

The Information does not provide and should not be treated as giving investment advice. The Information does not take into account specific investment objectives, financial situation or the particular needs of any prospective investor. No representation or warranty is made, expressed or implied, with respect to the fairness, correctness, accuracy, reasonableness or completeness of the Information. We do not undertake to update the Information. It should not be regarded by prospective investors as a substitute for the exercise of their own judgment or research. Prospective investors should consult with their own legal, regulatory, tax, business, investment, financial and accounting advisers to the extent that they deem it necessary, and make any investment decisions based upon their own judgment and advice from such advisers as they deem necessary and not upon any view expressed herein.

0 comments on “Grayscale GBTC and ETHE Arbitrage Risks

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: